A lesbian married couple, Christy Love and Syren De Mer, have been trying to get pregnant using sperm banks but to no avail. At their wit’s end, they decide that it may be time to consider another option: a live donor. But as they wonder WHO the prime candidate could be, their stepson Josh Rivers passes by, and they have their answer!

The two stepmoms convince Josh to be their sperm donor, but when it comes time to choose which stepmom will be the one to receive the sperm, Christy and Syren end up fighting over Josh in a tug-of-war. They quickly stop, and realize that the best way to decide is to have a threesome and let the creampie happen naturally!